1928 - Came only with 1928 1120, it has journal trucks The sides are rubber stamped "N.Y.C. & H.R. in pale white which is almost always worn off. We have found this tender with a couple 'different' engines that we can't explain.. Example - this No. 1100

Circa 1929 - die cast with brass plates and Type D 'M-Style' trucks 

Two No. 25 die cast tenders from 1929 - note that one on right has type D 'M trucks' and the one on left has type E 'M trucks'. Below are two red No. 25s from 1930 and the one on the right has type D 'M trucks' and one on the left has type E 'M trucks'.

Red No. 25 that came with the 1930 Black Diamond Set.

Copper No. 25 that came with the 1929 Major HOD Seagrave Special Deluxe set.

This one is actually Dorfan and was sold with the No. 770. It's marked Express and the decal to the far right should read '770'